A NATURAL REMEDY
Ross Duffy
Four months in custody awaiting trial, yet only three visits from my children.
They've said little, but I read it in their eyes: Mother, you have disgraced
us! How dare you shatter our orderly lives. So, thank God for Mary. My dear
friend has not once failed me - the maximum two gaol visits each week. And how I
relish her every arrival - and seeing her old-fashioned fair curls, joyful face
and heart-warming smile. Then the chirpy conversation. But once she leaves it's
all greyness again.
Of course, all my friends know I was incapable of this monstrous
crime. For years, Lyall and I had presented as a gentle, staid couple. And as
we'd drifted unpretentiously into our mid-fifties everyone had expected us to
quietly and modestly age in unison.
At the half-yearly parties for professors, lecturers and staff, Lyall and I
often ended up alone, stranded. No one was interested. One evening I overheard
Professor Eric Jansson whisper to his wife that Lyall was "as inspiring as a
deflated souffle." Ever-attentive Mary, a faculty secretary and organiser of all
these parties, was the one who normally came to our rescue.
Through all his years as a lecturer in political science, Lyall had stuck
to the plain dark suit - not for him the greasy suede jackets or baggy corduroy
trousers or colourful bow ties of the radical members of the university
fraternity. And even when he began thinning on top, he never aped his peers by
growing the compensating sideburns, beard or moustache.
Despite a first class intellect, Lyall's range of interests was narrow -
basically his own specialty, and bird life. He was an enthusiastic member of two
ornithological societies. Every Tuesday and Thursday night he'd set off
for their meetings.
Since my arrest I've had ample time to reflect upon
my life - for example how, like Lyall, I always found it difficult to exude
charm or bonhomie. Growing up in a Methodist manse must have left its mark. No
risque stories. No colourful make-up. I've never smoked, even in my teenage
phase. Just the occasional social drink. My hair has always been cut short and
straight, and my normal street attire has been...well, conservative: the plain
suit or twin-set. During her late teens, my daughter Margaret sometimes tagged
me "a frump" and cruelly contrasted me with her friends' mothers.
And, in my gloomy, sour-smelling cell, I've thought a lot about my
children. I'd really striven to provide a comforting home and a trouble-free
start to their lives. But I was a colossal failure! They are so self-centred.
They show me no warmth. For years, their visits home have mainly been when
they've wanted something. Was the fault mine? An inability to generate, or
transmit, motherly love? Did I err in even having children? Or perhaps it was my
discovery about Lyall that turned me...
Murder. What a hideous word! But my friends are adamant: The
police have made a dreadful mistake. They even organised a petition for my
release on bail: Because no court will ever convict this woman. I can readily
imagine their concerned chatter. 'Such a quiet, well-mannered couple' and
'Melva's so caring, so gentle - couldn't kill a fly, let alone her husband!' My
neighbours, Lottie and Bert Haydon, sent a beautiful card. Lottie penned the
words, Chin up. Any juror with half a brain will set you free in no
time. If my barrister agrees, they want to give character evidence.
But, I ask myself, how much do we really know about the lives of
others - once they're out of sight, that is? How devastated dear Lottie and Bert
would be if they knew that, after Lyall and I'd waved them goodbye at our front
gate, virtually all conversation ended - apart from Lyall's occasional bouts of
irrational nagging. And that's how it's been ever since that night, way
back in my third pregnancy, twenty-one years ago.
How far, I'd pondered, does a woman have to be pushed before her
personality changes? How much coldness, emptiness, and psychological pain does
it take? Over the years, I'd questioned why I didn't leave Lyall the moment I
found out. Yet, back then, it was a hard option. So for many lonely years I'd
paid the high price. But it's strange how, in time, we adapt to adversity and
get on with our daily life - particularly when there are children
involved.
The events of that night twenty-one years ago? In a flash, the
whole scene can return vividly. It's a Tuesday morning. I've mislaid some bird
pictures Tim wanted for kindergarten. I search everywhere. Perhaps Lyall
mistakenly gathered them up with his own documents? So I look in his study, then
turn to the small, black bag he takes to his ornithological meetings. To my
surprise, it's unlocked. And that's when I find the literature - several copies
of "Gay News."
I'm stunned. My knees are weak. But I decide I must follow him
that evening. On a pretext, I persuade Lottie to baby-sit. Lyall stays only
forty minutes at his ornithological meeting, then drives to Harvey Meldron's
second floor apartment. Breathlessly, I clamber up the rusty fire escape.
Through a gap in the curtains I see more than enough. And, in a flash, I
understand Lyall's lack of sexual interest in me for several years. There'd been
the occasional brief episode - but, surely, solely designed to divert suspicion,
to protect his relationship with Harvey?
When Lyall returns that night, he is remarkably frank. In an odd way, he
seems almost relieved. They'd become lovers as undergraduates. The affair had
continued until Harvey, a lecturer in biology, accepted an appointment at
Toronto University. It was during his three-year absence that Lyall and I had
met, and married.
'You bastard!' I scream through my tears. 'A practising homosexual - yet
you marry me. Why?' I struggle against the urge to rip his face to shreds.
'You've over-simplified the issue,' he replies, coolly. 'I've only ever
been with one man - Harvey. At first, I thought I'd never marry. But then I met
you. And you were so warm...so gentle. I felt we'd probably be alright.'
'Alright! You're a monster!' I weep. 'Why set out to ruin my
life?'
He pauses, apparently selecting his words carefully. 'Look, I really wanted
it to work out. I thought I'd be able to...to control my passions. And
to be honest, at that stage I couldn't see much chance of promotion in the
faculty - as a known homosexual, that is.'
His smug smile is too much for me. 'You selfish bastard!' I explode. 'I
could kill you.' I snatch the reading lamp from the coffee table and strike his
head. The globe shatters. Glass falls at his feet. Oddly, he just stands there,
small cuts oozing blood, as though awaiting another attack.
'Listen, Melva, at the beginning I really did try.' He is still
irritatingly calm. 'For a while, I even believed I had changed. But when Harvey
returned to the university I...well, realised I couldn't... '
'Well,' I hiss, 'after this baby's born, we're leaving you. And you can rot
in hell!'
Lyall steps over the broken glass and sits in an armchair. 'I don't think
that's wise. If the reason for your leaving becomes general knowledge, my
prospects with the faculty are zero. And what does no job mean? It means no
maintenance for wife and children. Even if I retain my present position, the
salary's too paltry to support two households.'
'Yes,' I fire back, 'you'll never get promotion. Too busy reading your gay
porn. Despite all your fancy qualifications, you're stuck in the rut as a
lecturer.' Oddly, the last comment scores a hit. For the first time, he
reddens.
He was right, in a cruel way. In those times, women forced to leave home
received little governmental assistance. I just couldn't inflict such hardship
on my children. So we stayed together - detesting each other, yet maintaining
the facade, acting out roles to deceive relatives and our few remaining friends.
But the separate beds, the atmosphere, the silences? Surely the children
knew?
Lyall continued to visit his lover regularly. Promotion never arrived. And
I adjusted my life, joined a music group, immersed myself in my beloved garden,
read, and later found...
Shortly after the children left home, I started contemplating divorce and
property settlement. Yet with so little to divide ...? Thanks to all the college
fees, there was still a hefty mortgage and only minor savings. The one
substantial asset, Lyall's superannuation, was available only on his retirement,
or death. If I'd forced a property settlement at that time, I'd have ended up in
dismal accommodation - certainly no beautiful, life-bracing garden!
What is the Crown's evidence to prove I murdered my husband? Well, its case
is tenuous. My veteran barrister, Shaun Mackie, is a wily court performer. He's
confident no jury will convict on such flimsy material - particularly after
they've seen me give evidence. And I'm looking forward to that.
It's now the sixth day of the trial. The Crown case has almost concluded.
It's still hard to accept that this entire elaborate performance is about
me! From the dock, I survey the whole archaic, yet dramatic, setting: the
stern-faced judge in his scarlet, ermine-edged robes; the barristers at the bar
table, impeccably dressed for their roles, in wigs and black gowns; the anxious
faces of the jurors, straining to evaluate every answer; the packed public
gallery. And there's dear loyal, trusting Mary, in her usual seat. I give her
yet another little wave and a smile.
Seven lay witnesses have now testified as to Lyall's appearance during his
final days and his complaints of mild nausea and dizziness. He was never one to
consult doctors. My barrister doesn't dispute the opinion formed by the Crown's
medical witnesses: Death as the result of ingesting a toxic glycoside commonly
found in the Oleander shrub. It was probably administered, in the form of an
infusion of Oleander leaves, over several days. But the critical questions
remaining are: How? And by whom? Was it at the university - in Lyall's several
daily coffees, or in his cafeteria lunches? If so, with what motive? Or was it
at home - by me?
The Crown has led evidence of my passion for gardening. When the police
searched our home they found Dangerous Plants in
Australia. Naturally, the Crown Prosecutor has sought to make
capital out of the faint crease at the top of page 107, where the corner had
once been turned over, and the passage below:
Nerium Oleander
Fatal poisoning can be caused by chewing the stems or leaves of the
Oleander bush or drinking water into which such leaves have fallen...
At the end of our street, in the reserve where I regularly walk my
Pekingese, there are several Oleanders. Mrs Romano, a renowned nosy parker, has
testified that on two separate occasions she saw me pluck leaves from these
bushes. But she's doddery and her eyesight's fading. Besides, her house is
nearly eighty metres from the reserve. Shaun Mackie's cross-examination was
brilliant. So I don't expect the jury will give much weight to her evidence -
particularly when faced with my denials.
Potentially, the most damaging evidence is the discovery, in one of my
saucepans, of a minute trace of the alleged poison. The Crown's theory is that
I'd boiled the leaves in water before adding the liquid to my husband's food or
drink. But nothing was detected on any cup, saucer, plate or other utensil. And
my forensic experts contend the trace found in that saucepan was not the
substance that killed Lyall. Further, they have innocent explanations as to how
it probably got there. Mr Mackie assures me the jury will be much too confused
to convict on such a conflicting jumble of evidence.
The Crown's major difficulty has always been the absence of motive. But
then, yesterday, there was a sensational development. Just as Harvey Meldron was
describing Lyall's appearance in his last days, he suddenly broke down and
pointed a shaking hand at me. My life's ruined, he blurted. That woman's killed
my lover!
I noted the Prosecutor's instant glee - and Shaun Mackie's dismay. (I'd
agonised for ages before deciding not to disclose the homosexual relationship to
Mackie.) But the Prosecutor's hopes were immediately dashed by Harvey's next
answers: their affair had begun twenty-nine years earlier, and I'd known for
twenty-one. Surely the jury wouldn't believe I'd wait that long to take
revenge?
The trial will end within three days. I'm confident I'll then be set free
to join my wonderful, devoted lover. Free to hold each other caringly, entwine
bodies, meld lips, invade secret places. It's incredible - seven years on, and
our passion continues to grow.
It hasn't been easy, but now I've decided that once I'm acquitted there'll
be no more furtive, stolen hours. We have already selected our piece of paradise
- thankfully Lyall's superannuation monies will fund the purchase price. When
the countryside is ablaze in morning sunshine, from our bedroom window we'll
gaze out upon a sparkling stream flanked by towering gums, lush undulating green
fields and multi-coloured bird life.
Gracefully winding its way to the house is a long, white gravel driveway. I
haven't told dear, trusting Mary yet but, naturally, my first gardening task
when we move in will be to line the driveway with Oleanders.
After retiring as a
barrister, eleven years ago Ross Duffy turned to writing short stories. Total
now 102. Many have won awards in short story competitions around Australia, many
have been published in magazines, newspapers and anthologies and about 15 of the
shorter ones have been read on radio. About 40 of the 102 involve a legal
character or a courtroom setting. The balance have nothing to do with the legal
scene!
Vintage Trunks